We just had our first group meeting of the year. Sponsorship plans and upcoming events. We aim to be a finalist in 25th KBP Golden Dove Awards, of course. I’m going to revamp my broadcaster image and introduce a new segment. Just you wait!
The Sarihay Media Awards, organized by the Foundation for the Philippine Environment, “recognizes and showcases the country’s best reportage of environmental issues across traditional and digital media platforms in the past year.” Dr. Custer was chosen as a finalist for his Pinoy Scientist episode entry National Greening Program & the Magic of Mycorrhizae. (arguably one of the best episodes produced since it was also included in our KBP Golden Dove Awards entry) And I’m not surprised that he has been hailed the winner in the Best Radio Commentary category, for the second time now. XD
In stark contrast with the Golden Dove Awards last April, this time Dr. Custer has a speech prepared. And it was both heartwearming and hilarious when he called on us one by one to highlight our uniqueness as a group and individual strengths: Dr. Guido as one of the Philippine representatives to the International Mathematical Olympiad (aptly called “olympics for math wizards”, haha), Dr. JD for being the “nag-iisang makatang siyentista”, and me for being a “big data analytics expert(???)”. Lol! Thanks for sharing the glory with us (but I’d rather not have the spotlight on myself next time, thanks!)
The first media event where all four of us are present, yay! I have long dreamed of this moment. In an extremely introverted and antisocial way, I say this: I am so glad to be part of this group.
It was my first time to be on-air for Pinoy Scientist yesterday. Our guest scientists for the “Science, Technology and Society” episode were Dr. Sonia Jacinto of the UP Diliman Institute of Biology and Dr. Ginny Cruz, soon to be a DOST Balik Scientist.
Dr. Sonia talked about plant extracts in cancer research, while Dr. Ginny discussed chemisthesis, her work as a chemosensory neuroscientist, and the connection between Sci & Tech and society.
It turns out that the extent of my fear of public speaking happens to include broadcasting. Even Dr. Guido found that a bit ridiculous ’cause it doesn’t involve a physical audience, but… I can’t help but feel uptight about the whole thing because at the very core I am afraid of messing up. PS is a nationwide program after all (and the fact that my family would be tuning in just added to the pressure :(( ). I bypassed the liquor ban and drank a few shots of whiskey before the show but it didn’t completely dispel my nervousness. I was so awkward and couldn’t even express myself well in Filipino. 😦 Good thing Dr. JD was very considerate and Deewai went with us to give some moral support. 😀
All that stress, and I’m going to have to experience it every other Sunday! D: Well, joining the team has always been my choice and I don’t regret it. I can’t watch the interview video without cringing at this point, but I’m glad that things will get better from here as I gradually improve (otherwise that would suck, haha). I just have to be able to prepare more for the interviews and learn to ask better questions.
At last, the Pinoy Siyentista Group was able to hold a successful meeting, thanks to Dr. JD’s insistence and the tempting promise of free food (JK. but Dr.JD really made the effort to prepare a feast for us, and everything was delish). It was of utmost importance since we’ve been really uncoordinated as a group lately, unable to carry out some the projects that were planned for the election season.
I’m impressed that the meeting turned out to be more organized. Of course a lot of new projects were brought up, but this time Dr. Custer took down notes on the implementation brainstorming (I recorded the proceedings on my phone just in case). Our individual roles were given definition:
External affairs: Dr. Custer
General manager: Dr. JD
Business & promotion: Dr. Guido (though I’m pretty sure he’ll delegate some of his tasks to me)
Website: me (ugh, I can’t wait to have a “Dr.” title XD )
Concrete strategies to make the show flourish and win more mass media awards were discussed. And Dr. Custer, being an out-of-this-world thinker, proposed a few ideas exactly of that nature (secret, for the time being XD ).
It’s amusing how my academic “barkada” of 40+ year olds seem to be far more passionate about life than me, whose youth elicits a tinge of envy among them XD but their drive is, as always, amazingly inspirational. 😀
It’s official, our radio show is now award-winning! * u * Thanks to the efforts of Dr. Custer and company, Pinoy Scientist bagged the title Best Science and Technology Radio Program at the prestigious 24th KBP Golden Dove Awards, along with the highly coveted shiny trophy that came with it.
That afternoon, Dr. Custer instructed the team to attend the event so Dr. JD asked me to accompany her. She literally dragged me away from Dr. Guido (who decided not to come in order to enjoy his birthday leave) to her car as it started to rain (which would’ve made for a dramatic scene had he chased after me XD ). Anyway, that incredibly long travel was worth it. I got to see Dr. Custer in the flesh once again, and he offered to make me a research assistant for a groundbreaking project in the works, which I accepted right off the bat because I want to work on something more scientific for my master’s degree (and partly because I was flattered that he sees value in me XD ).
According to Dr. Custer, the show has consistently been a finalist in the S&T program category for 3 years now. But we weren’t actually expecting to win because some of the nominees we met before the event told us that they were already informed of whether they won or not, whereas we didn’t have an idea, so we entertained the possibility that we weren’t informed because we didn’t win so we simply enjoyed the food (especially Dr. Custer, haha). I jokingly told him to craft a speech just in case. I readied my camera to capture that moment too, just in case.
So when Pinoy Scientist did get called onstage to receive the award, I was shocked that they wanted me to come with them as a representative as well. :O I was overwhelmed so I didn’t get to say a word in front of the mic. XD So was Dr. Custer, who thankfully managed to improvise something about this venture being a scientist’s adventure or something, and Dr. JD, who unfortunately forgot to say her tagline “Happiness”. The event is going to be televised so if you happen to catch it, you’ll see how awkward we were (then again, who expects scientists to do well in highly social situations? XD ).
We had a short photo session with the golden dove trophy (too bad Dr. Guido wasn’t around) and left right away to catch the last train rides, but not before crossing paths with Dr. Roque (my institute’s director and calculus professor), the driving force behind our rival S&T show. Dr. Custer and JD were super extra happy that night, inspired to improve the show for future mass media awards (note that Dr. Custer loves competitions XD ). Me, I’m just proud to be part of this award-winning venture and happy that I’ll be able to make a big contribution to the show too, really soon. 🙂
For a Pinoy Scientist episode, our group (w/ Dr. Custer and Dr. Guido) interviewed Dr. Jeffrey Beall, the creator of Beall’s List, through a video conference. I honestly had no idea who he was or what the significance of his initiative is (or even how his name was spelled, haha) beforehand. But I did overhear that it is a controversial topic in the scholarly environment, and since I am to forge an unorthodox path to the academe, I figured that this is something worth knowing. Here is what I picked up from the interview:
His biggest contribution to the academe is a blacklist of journals. The 900 or so publishers in Beall’s list are said to be mostly predatory or hijacked (or just plain sketchy). He defines predatory journals as those that take advantage of the Gold open access model in an unethical manner. It is quite normal for some journals to charge a publication fee from the author, but the main issue against predatory journals is that this business model can be exploited to prioritize the revenue without regard for the quality of the papers they accept. Hijacked journals, on the other hand, are journals the general look and feel of which were counterfeited from legitimate journals to deceive authors into publishing there instead (evil twins!).
Some of the criteria he uses to judge whether a journal deserves to be in the list are:
- dishonest/unhealthy peer review
- spammy (spelling, grammar, math mistakes)
- lesser known but looks strangely familiar
- easily accepts papers or promises rapid publishing (too good to be true!)
Beall continually maintains his list through feedback (it’s said to be currently in its 3rd edition) and notifies people of recent additions through his blog and twitter. What makes it controversial is that some of the items in his blacklist also belong to some existing whitelists. For example, I found out from Nature that he took some heat for adding Frontiers (reason: publishing 2 pseudoscientific articles, deeming its standards questionable) to his list despite its reputation for being a well-patronized journal. Some scholars try to discredit his list (and even give lawsuit threats they never really act on, haha) and accuse him of basing it purely on his intuition, but in my opinion, one should not disregard intuition in quality control since it could be the only way to detect intricate deceit (or expertly-disguised stupidity) hiding behind flawless logic.
Fortunately, the most of the feedback he garners are positive. There’s no doubt that academia needs journal police like him to protect researchers all over the world from falling prey to predatory journals.
Some advice from Beall to people who are starting out on their academic career:
- Citing articles from predatory journals is risky. Taking advantage of them for tenure will most likely compromise credibility.
- Take whitelists and blacklists with a grain of salt.
- Publish in good journals. They don’t have to be top journals, as long as they’re high-quality.
THE MODERN LIBRARIAN
The onset of the digital age brought about an obvious change in learning media. Most information are now online, but Beall says that does not mean less people read books nowadays — they simply switched from print to ebooks. Thanks to that, the role of librarians have evolved as well, from being simply custodians of books to being pioneers in improving access to and adding value to information. According to him, the electronic environment also makes a librarian’s life easier, as it automates the process of search and lending. And of course, they have an easier time with helping researchers.
[Fun fact: There are more libraries that McDonald’s branches in Denver. Unlike in the Philippines. XD)
- He likes reading books about volcanoes, nature, and astronomy, but he hasn’t had enough time to read lately.
- He also likes driving to mountains (Denver is a mountainous region, after all).
- Being a single man, he finds joy in traveling for academic talks.
- His website is self-maintained and he has no time to collaborate (Dr. Custer has a habit of offering a collaboration to guests, haha).